Forum:Xwing327's situation

This forum is for CABAL members to reply on and discuss the topic at hand.

Just tonight, User:Xwing327 confessed that he is in fact User:Trask Ulgo/User:Jango Fett/etc. Now, since the rules apply to everyone, he should get a ban according to this. Since he was evading a ban and this is another sockpuppeting account of his (Jango Fett --> Trask Ulgo was the first). He wasn't banned infinitely for sockpuppeting though. According to the policy, he should be banned for 2 weeks and have the inability to vote for 6 months.

He was actually banned excessive personal attacks over the IRC.

So the question to my fellow CABAL members is this: Should he be banned for the "2 weeks/6 months voting penalty" only, since he hasn't committed to personal attacks and such again? Or, since technically he has been sockpuppeting a lot over time (but before the blocking policy was established) should he be banned infinitely again? OR, should he be banned infinitely according to the reason he was originally banned infinitely for (PAs)?

I would make this decision myself, but this is one of those situations where I feel the other members of the CABAL should put their word in, in accordance to the rules.

I would prefer it if only CABAL members responded to this, though, other users are welcome to give their input. -- Don Victor, Sr.  ( contact ) 04:51, 3 November 2007 (UTC)