Forum:CT:Revamping the no joke articles policy

TK-999 recently proposed and got approved some changes to Star Wars Fanon:No joke articles policy. That was a good step, but I'd like to finish what that started by proposing a revamp of that policy.

This revamp can be found here, and adopts the changes TK proposed.

What I did was simplify it a bit more, add in what the spirit of the policy is meant to be (it's a very subjective policy, so the spirit needs to be clear), and kept the current peer review process (with a few minor tweaks).

I propose that we adopt this policy rewrite. I also propose that Star Wars Fanon:No joke articles policy be renamed to Star Wars Fanon:Joke articles policy. The former was originally chosen because... I don't really know why, but I think it's confusing and poorly thought out. I've offered keeping it as an option, though.

This CT will last for one week, until Saturday, November 17, 2012, unless more or less time is required. All relevant matters of the voting policy apply. Please be civil.

Revamp the policy, change the name

 * 1) As the proposer. - Brandon Rhea (talk)  18:34, November 10, 2012 (UTC)