Thread:SavageOpress1138/@comment-104549-20151215121224/@comment-3528596-20151216021221

So here's what I'd say. The community has ruled that the Soulcalibur articles can stay. Fine. Given the other decisions and discussions I've linked to above, and my own interpretation of the policy, I think the Transformers is a crossover. It is neither legendarily nor canonically accepted, and technically the toy line doesn't even involve Star Wars characters interacting with Transformers characters.

IMHO, the Soulcalibur decision should be viewed as the exception, not the rule. In other words, the community voted that Soulcalibur should be allowed despite it qualifying as a crossover.