Thread:Brandon Rhea/@comment-25898954-20150603185356/@comment-3528596-20150605154609

Hey you two. I'm going to interject a couple of things here. First of all, let's just take a minute to look at the Star Wars Fanon: Participation Guidelines. Let's try and work a little harder at assuming good faith, being civil, and not participating in edit wars. Neither one of you is out to get the other, and comments like "don't play with me" and "is that so hard to grasp" are both clearly aggressive and not working to defuse the situation.

Now, personally, I agree with Firedance. The page is meant to be a list of the various fanon CIS groups. You can absolutely make your own CIS page where they are the clear heroes of the Clone Wars, but that doesn't belong on the disambiguation page. In Goodwood's original summary, they are described as the antagonists of the Clone Wars. Antagonist is defined by Google as "a person who actively opposes or is hostile to someone or something; an adversary." Using that definition, the CIS is certainly the antagonist of the Clone Wars. Does that make them 100% evil, no. That said, calling them heroes is a huge stretch for me.

But that's my opinion. I'm willing to wait for Brandon's opinion also, to give you guys another outside opinion. Either way, in the future let's try to deal with these situations more calmly.