Forum:HP and DL feedback

I can't speak for the HPs, but it's been about a month since the wiki had its HP elections and a couple weeks since the DL elections concluded. That said, I couldn't find a specific page for this on either the HP or DL pages, so I decided to make a Senate Hall page. This page will serve as a general feedback page for the community to give feedback on the overall performances of the High Priests and Decreton Lords. Remember to comment on content, not contributor. This is a good place to clear up confusion about the rules or the procedure for FAs and GAs. This is a good place to ask about any FA or GA reviews, such as that languishing Third FA review. It is not a good place to flame the HPs and DLs, who will likely not pay you any attention and/or never review anything of yours again and/or summon an admin to deal with you. Remember, only you can give them the feedback they need to hear and ignore in order to serve the community and do their job correctly.

The second purpose of this page is to discuss something called "line-by-line reviewing." It's not generally been used in the past, but involves reading an article line-by-line and checking it for errors, ala Wookieepedia's FA and GA pages. For those of you who hate the mention of anything Wookieepedia being imported to SWF, ignore that last phrase. I've used it, I know Rhea has started to use it, as well as Darth tom. I'm sure there are others, so don't get offended if I didn't mention you. This basically means picking the article apart sentence by sentence in an attempt to make it high quality and usually involves a long laundry list of objections. If you don't believe me, just look at the FAN page. This has most certainly not been used in the past. When last I talked to Rhea in IRC, he seemed to imply that the use of line-by-line (LBL) was now standard practice among all HPs and DLs. . . I don't recall seeing that general notice posted anywhere, so apparently, Rhea wants all of you HP and DL types to read everything! FYI. BTW, this doesn't mean that every DL or HP needs to LBL every article (in particular, Solus does a great job of checking articles for other things like links and pics) and there's no point in LBLing something that's 100 KB of Mary Sue. (You know what I'm talking about.) In fact, that would be a patent waste of time. So post some thoughts and opinions here.

Discuss.

Discussion
For any FAN writers who are looking at a big list of stuff to do from "Teh Desk of Ataru" and want to yell at me for it, go ahead. My talk page is always open. . . the response is always the same.