Star Wars Fanon:Deletion page/G-4178's Log Journal vol 1 prt1

G-4178's Log Journal (all pages)

 * Arguments for deletion:


 * This "narrative"&mdash;and I use that term very loosely&mdash;is among the worst that I have ever read. It is saturated with spelling and grammar errors, and I can provide examples if need be. There are very few sentences in this thing and the discombobulated thoughts that comprise the bulk of its content are disjointed and separated by two dots that I presume are supposed to be ellipses. The tense is anything but consistent. Fails to follow SWF:MOS on any number of levels with regards to grammar and spelling.
 * It does not follow the Layout Guide. There is no infobox, and it's not formatted as a subpage, which would preclude that requirement from being applicable.
 * There appears to be OOU dates scattered through this thing. E.g. 7/19/05, and so. Another violation of MOS.
 * It fails to follow the content policy. From a very casual skimming, I can see that this is suffused with gratuitous violence and decorated with excessive and pointless (as well as grammatically incorrect) profanity, including words specifically prohibited by policy.
 * The author has not made any contributions since October of 2008. I doubt very much that he/she is willing to put forth the labor needed to perform a total overhaul on this atrocity.

This VFD applies to this page, G-4178's Log Journal vol 2 prt1, and G-4178's Log Journal Volume 3 Part 1 which are almost identically awful in their plethora of errors and policy violations. Atarumaster88  ( Talk page ) 16:48, 29 July 2009 (UTC)

Support

 * 1) With extreme prejudice. This thing is an insult to the English language and should not go unpunished for its juvenile quality and total disregard for most of SWF's policies in terms of content and style. I'm very surprised this wasn't mass deleted. Atarumaster88  Jedi_Order.svg ( Talk page ) 16:48, 29 July 2009 (UTC)